The Audi S4. Just the name conjures images of spirited drives, sleek design, and a refined blend of performance and luxury. But is the S4 truly a "good car"? That's the question many potential buyers wrestle with as they weigh its pros and cons against other performance sedans. After all, a car is a significant investment, and you want to ensure you're making the right choice. This analysis dives deep into the S4, exploring its performance capabilities, reliability, comfort, technology, and overall value proposition to help you determine if it's the right fit for your needs.

Performance That Puts a Smile on Your Face

The heart of any performance sedan is its engine, and the S4 doesn't disappoint. Equipped with a turbocharged 3.0-liter V6, the S4 delivers impressive power and torque. We're talking around 349 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque, which translates to exhilarating acceleration. Zero to 60 mph times typically hover around the 4.5-second mark, putting it squarely in the realm of serious performance cars. But it's not just about straight-line speed.

  • Handling: Audi's quattro all-wheel-drive system provides exceptional grip and stability, inspiring confidence in all weather conditions. The S4 feels planted and responsive in corners, making it a joy to drive on twisty roads.
  • Transmission: The S4 typically comes with an eight-speed automatic transmission that offers smooth and quick shifts. While some enthusiasts might miss a manual option, the automatic is well-tuned and contributes to the car's overall performance.
  • Driving Modes: Audi's drive select system allows you to tailor the car's performance to your preferences. You can choose from modes like Comfort, Auto, Dynamic, and Individual, adjusting parameters such as throttle response, steering feel, and suspension stiffness (if equipped with adaptive dampers).

The S4 strikes a great balance between performance and everyday usability. It's powerful enough to be exciting, yet comfortable enough for daily commutes.

Luxury and Comfort: A Classy Interior

Stepping inside the S4, you're greeted by a well-crafted and luxurious interior. Audi is known for its attention to detail, and the S4 is no exception.

  • Materials: High-quality materials are used throughout the cabin, including leather upholstery, aluminum trim, and soft-touch plastics. The overall fit and finish are excellent, giving the S4 a premium feel.
  • Seating: The front seats are supportive and comfortable, even on long drives. They offer ample adjustability, allowing you to find the perfect driving position. The rear seats are reasonably spacious for adults, although taller passengers might find legroom a bit tight.
  • Technology: The S4 comes standard with a range of advanced technology features, including Audi's virtual cockpit, a digital instrument cluster that displays important information in a clear and customizable format. The infotainment system is intuitive and easy to use, with a responsive touchscreen display.

The S4's interior is a comfortable and stylish place to spend time, making it a great choice for those who value both performance and luxury.

Technology That Enhances the Driving Experience

Modern cars are packed with technology, and the Audi S4 is no exception. Here's a closer look at some of the key tech features:

  • Audi Virtual Cockpit: As mentioned earlier, the virtual cockpit is a standout feature. It replaces traditional analog gauges with a high-resolution digital display that can be customized to show various information, such as navigation maps, performance data, and media controls.
  • Infotainment System: The MMI infotainment system is user-friendly and offers a wide range of features, including Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, navigation, and a premium sound system.
  • Driver-Assistance Features: The S4 comes standard with a suite of driver-assistance features, such as automatic emergency braking, lane departure warning, and blind-spot monitoring. These features can help to enhance safety and reduce driver fatigue. Optional features like adaptive cruise control and park assist are also available.

The S4's technology features are well-integrated and enhance both the driving experience and overall safety.

Reliability: A Mixed Bag

Reliability is a crucial factor to consider when buying any car, and the Audi S4's track record is somewhat mixed.

  • Potential Issues: Some common issues reported by S4 owners include problems with the water pump, thermostat, and timing chain tensioner. These issues can be expensive to repair, so it's important to be aware of them.
  • Maintenance: Regular maintenance is essential to keep the S4 running smoothly. Be sure to follow the recommended service schedule and address any issues promptly.
  • Warranty: A comprehensive warranty can provide peace of mind. Consider purchasing an extended warranty to protect yourself against unexpected repair costs.

While the S4 can be a reliable car, it's important to be aware of potential issues and to maintain it properly. Consulting reliability ratings from sources like J.D. Power and Consumer Reports can provide further insights into the S4's reliability. Pre-purchase inspections by a qualified mechanic are also highly recommended, especially for used models.

Value for Money: Is the S4 Worth the Price?

The Audi S4 occupies a competitive segment of the market, facing rivals like the BMW M340i, Mercedes-AMG C43, and Cadillac CT5-V. Determining whether the S4 offers good value for money depends on your individual needs and priorities.

  • Pricing: The S4 typically starts at a price point that's competitive with its rivals. However, the price can quickly escalate with options and packages.
  • Depreciation: Like most cars, the S4 will depreciate over time. However, its strong brand reputation and performance capabilities help it to retain its value relatively well.
  • Running Costs: In addition to the purchase price, you'll also need to factor in running costs such as fuel, insurance, and maintenance. The S4's performance engine can be thirsty, and maintenance costs can be higher than average.

The S4 offers a compelling blend of performance, luxury, and technology. If these are your priorities, it can represent good value for money. However, if you're on a tight budget or prioritize reliability above all else, you might want to consider other options. Comparing the S4 to its competitors based on your specific needs is crucial for making an informed decision.

Potential S4 Model Years to Consider (and Ones to Avoid)

Navigating the used car market requires a bit of research, especially when it comes to specific model years. Here's a quick guide to help you identify potential sweet spots and years that might come with more headaches:

  • 2018-Present (B9.5 Generation): Generally considered a solid choice. Audi refined the B9 platform with updated styling, improved technology, and addressed some of the earlier reliability concerns. Look for models with complete service records.
  • 2017 (B9 Generation): The first year of the B9 generation. While offering a significant upgrade over the previous generation, some early models might have had teething issues. Thorough inspection is crucial.
  • 2013-2016 (B8.5 Generation): This generation is generally reliable, but it's getting older, meaning potential maintenance items might be due. Check for timing chain issues and water pump leaks.
  • Earlier Models (Pre-2013): While potentially more affordable, older models will likely require more maintenance and might not have the latest technology features. Proceed with caution and a detailed inspection.

Key takeaway: Newer models (2018+) typically offer the best balance of features, performance, and reliability, but they also come with a higher price tag. Older models can be a good value if properly maintained, but they require more due diligence.

S4 vs. The Competition: How Does It Stack Up?

The Audi S4 doesn't exist in a vacuum. It faces stiff competition from other performance sedans. Here's a quick comparison:

  • BMW M340i: Often considered the S4's closest rival. The M340i offers similar performance and handling, but with a slightly more aggressive driving experience.
  • Mercedes-AMG C43: The C43 provides a blend of luxury and performance, but it might not be as engaging to drive as the S4 or M340i.
  • Cadillac CT5-V: The CT5-V offers American muscle car vibes with a comfortable interior and competitive pricing.
  • Genesis G70 3.3T: The G70 offers excellent value for money with a stylish design, potent engine, and a long list of features.

The best choice depends on your priorities. If you value a refined driving experience and a luxurious interior, the S4 is a strong contender. If you prefer a more aggressive and sporty feel, the M340i might be a better fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Is the Audi S4 expensive to maintain? Yes, the S4 can be more expensive to maintain than a typical sedan due to its performance engine and complex systems.
  • Is the Audi S4 reliable? Reliability is mixed. Some owners report few issues, while others experience problems with the water pump, thermostat, and timing chain.
  • Does the Audi S4 have good gas mileage? Fuel economy is decent for a performance sedan, typically around 21 mpg city and 30 mpg highway.
  • Is the Audi S4 a good daily driver? Yes, the S4 strikes a good balance between performance and comfort, making it suitable for daily commutes.
  • Does the Audi S4 hold its value well? The S4 holds its value relatively well due to its strong brand reputation and performance capabilities.

The Verdict: Is the Audi S4 a Good Car?

Ultimately, the answer to the question "Are Audi S4 good cars?" is a resounding yes, with a few important caveats. The S4 offers a compelling combination of performance, luxury, and technology, making it a desirable choice for those seeking a sporty and refined sedan. However, it's important to be aware of potential reliability issues and higher maintenance costs. Thorough research, careful inspection, and a comprehensive warranty can help to mitigate these risks and ensure a satisfying ownership experience.